CITY OF ROCHESTER ROCHESTER PRESERVATION BOARD -Wednesday, January 7, 2026 Meeting with Staff: 5:00 PM - 5:45 PM Conference Room, Room 223B PUBLIC HEARING Begins 6:00 PM City Council Chambers, Room 302A I. Public Hearing Please note that this hearing will take place in person at Rochester City Hall, 30 Church Street, Room 302A Case: 1 File Number: A-037-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Landscaping Address: 80 Culver Road Zoning District: O-S Open Space and Cobb's Hill Preservation Districts Applicant: Sara Scott, City of Rochester Request: To remove thirteen (13) trees along the outfield of baseball fields #2, #3, and #4. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: NYCCR 617.5(c)(8) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 2 File Number: A-038-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Electric Vehicle Charging Station Address: 42 Atkinson Street Zoning District: R-3 High Density Residential and Corn Hill/Third Ward Preservation Districts, and City Designated Landmark Applicant: Keith Davis, Owner Request: To mount a single-sided electric vehicle charging station on the exterior of the rear yard detached garage. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: NYCCR 617.5(c)(12) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 3 File Number: A-039-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Roof Address: 84 Argyle Street Zoning District: R-3 High Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: William Welch, Owner Request: To install a standing seam bronze roof on the front porch, an EPDM roof on the rear addition, remove the rear door roof structure, and remove the rear chimney. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 4 File Number: A-040-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Signs Address: 39 South Goodman Street Zoning District: C-1 Neighborhood Center and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Beth Stanley, Tenant Request: To install one non-illuminated attached 40"W X 15"H (4.17SF) hanging sign on front porch and one non-illuminated detached 24"W X 15"H (2.5SF) sign on existing post in the front yard both reading 'Old Friends Tattoo.' Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(f) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 5 File Number: A-042-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Garage Address: 103 Argyle Street Zoning District: R-3 High Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Tim Kayes, Owner Request: To construct a two-car detached garage in the rear yard. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: NYCCR 617.5(c)(12) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 6 File Number: A-043-25-26 Case Type: Conceptual Review - Exterior Renovations Address: 759 Park Avenue Zoning District: R-1 Low Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Jonathan Swan, Developer Request: To review the concept to renovate the exterior of 759 Park Avenue for conversion into a Hotel. Code Section: N/A Enforcement: No SEQR: N/A Lead Agency: N/A Case: 7 File Number: A-044-25-26 Case Type: Conceptual Review - Exterior Renovations Address: 37-39 North Goodman Street Zoning District: R-3 High Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Don Lasher, Capstone Development Request: To review the concept to renovate the exterior of 37-39 North Goodman Street, an existing office building. Code Section: N/A Enforcement: No SEQR: N/A Lead Agency: N/A Comment Information Interested parties may comment on any particular case. Comments may be provided in person at the public hearing or submitted in writing by email or mail. Written comments must be received by 4:00 p.m. on January 6, 2026, at: Email: Preservationboard@CityofRochester.Gov Address: Rochester Preservation Board, 30 Church St. Rm. 125-B, Rochester, NY 14614 For more information, visit: https://www.cityofrochester.gov/presboard. 4120031 12-18-1t