CITY OF ROCHESTER ROCHESTER PRESERVATION BOARD -Wednesday, March 4, 2026 Meeting with Staff: 5:00 PM - 5:45 PM Conference Room, Room 208A PUBLIC HEARING Begins 6:00 PM City Council Chambers, Room 302A I. Public Hearing Please note that this hearing will take place in person at Rochester City Hall, 30 Church Street, Room 302A Case: 1 *Held from the August 6, 2025, Hearing Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Doors Address: 445 Frederick Douglass Street, Immaculate Conception Church Zoning District: R-3 High Density Residential and City Designated Landmark Applicant: Father Raymond Fleming, Pastor Request: To remove all six wood exterior doors and replace them with either solid wood or fiberglass options. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 2 File Number: A-045-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Windows and Garage Address: 22-24 Oxford Street Zoning District: R-2 Medium Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Michael Mummery, Owner Request: To legalize the replacement of 33 wood windows with vinyl replacements, and the removal and replacement of a detached three-car garage. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: Yes; The work was completed without a COA or permits. SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 3 File Number: A-046-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Doors Address: 7 South Madison Park Zoning District: R-2 Medium Density Residential and Susan B. Anthony Preservation Districts Applicant: Delois Crawford, Owner Request: To replace the side metal door with a painted steel door, and to replace the front metal door with a customized fiberglass door. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 4 File Number: A-048-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Exterior Renovations Address: 37-39 North Goodman Street Zoning District: R-3 High Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Don Lasher, Capstone Development Request: To renovate the exterior of 37-39 North Goodman Street, an existing office building, and provide minor site improvements. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 5 File Number: A-049-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Signs Address: 1243-1245 Park Avenue Zoning District: R-1 Low Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Michael Carducci, Owner Request: To legalize the installation of two vinyl window decals measuring 29"x14" (2.82 SF), and 24"x15" (2.5 SF) reading "Frost & Foundry Ice Cream" located on the storefront window and door. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: Yes; The violations are unrelated to this project. SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(f) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 6 File Number: A-050-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Windows Address: 1577 East Avenue Zoning District: R-3 High Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Jeff Babey, Owner Request: To replace eight additional aluminum windows with Anderson 400 series. Four windows were previously approved and replaced in 2024. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a) Lead Agency: N/A Comment Information Interested parties may comment on any particular case. Comments may be provided in person at the public hearing or submitted in writing by email or mail. Written comments must be received by 4:00 p.m. on March 3, 2026, at: Email: Preservationboard@CityofRochester.Gov Address: Rochester Preservation Board, 30 Church St. Rm. 125-B, Rochester, NY 14614 For more information, visit: https://www.cityofrochester.gov/presboard.4134977 2-12-1t