CITY OF ROCHESTER ROCHESTER PRESERVATION BOARD -Wednesday, June 3, 2026 Meeting with Staff: 5:00 PM - 5:45 PM Conference Room, Room 208A PUBLIC HEARING Begins 6:00 PM City Council Chambers, Room 302A I. Public Hearing Please note that this hearing will take place in person at Rochester City Hall, 30 Church Street, Room 302A Case: 1 File Number: A-070-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Signage Address: 80 Culver Road Zoning District: O-S Open Space and Cobb's Hill Preservation Districts and City-Designated Landmark Applicant: Sara Scott, City of Rochester Request: To install park shelter signage at two new park shelters measuring 11"x 18" (1.38 SF each), reading "Sugar Maple Shelter". Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(f) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 2 File Number: A-065-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Windows and Awning Address: 517 University Avenue Zoning District: R-3 High-Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Joseph Hanna, Owner Request: To remove and replace 343 wood windows with aluminum-clad wood windows and to install an awning over the front entrance. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a)&(g) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 3 File Number: A-066-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Fence Address: 81 Atkinson Street Zoning District: R-3 High-Density Residential and Corn Hill/Third Ward Preservation Districts Applicant: John Nnodum, Owner Request: To install a cast-iron antique fence 39" H x 28' L along the front yard of a multi-family residence. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(d) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 4 File Number: A-067-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Sign and Awning Address: 647-651 Park Avenue Zoning District: C-2 Community Center and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Ryan Martin, Tenant Request: To establish an alternative sign program for MJ Dispensary, which includes one attached building sign 250"x18" (31.25 SF), two awning signs 5.5' x 7" (6.42 SF), and one awning sign 4.25' x 4' (17SF), together totaling 4 signs, 54.67 SF. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(c) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(f) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 5 File Number: A-068-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Patio Address: 1166 Park Avenue Zoning District: R-2 Medium-Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Tim Dunkel, Owner Request: To legalize the removal of the wooden deck in the rear yard and replace it with a 12' W x 13.5' L x 21" H (162 SF) raised patio. Also, to legalize the paver walkway adjacent to the patio. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(b) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 6 File Number: A-069-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Porch Address: 325 Park Avenue Zoning District: R-2 Medium-Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Arthur Morris, Tickle Realty Request: To remove the existing concrete and flagstone porch floor, stairs, and steel posts, and replace them with a new porch that includes new columns, stairs, and handrails. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 7 File Number: A-071-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Interior Landmark and Signage Address: 200 East Avenue Zoning District: CCD-E Center City East End District and City-Designated Landmark Applicant: Chaise Williams, Tenant Request: To remove the cabinetry installed in 2011 and install new flooring in its place. Additionally, construct a 290-square-foot wooden bar and replace the Spot Coffee signage with Echelon Lounge branding. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a)&(f) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 8 File Number: A-072-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Roof and Door Address: 766 West Broad Street Zoning District: R-1 Low-Density Residential District and City-Designated Landmark Applicant: Clarence Turner, Christ Temple Apostle Faith Church Request: To remove existing roofing down to the deck and install new fiberglass asphalt architectural shingles. Additionally, remove and replace the front entry door with a new steel door. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 9 File Number: A-073-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Signs Address: 735-739 Park Avenue Zoning District: C-2 Community Center and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Andrew Lytwynec, Sphinx Head Holdings LLC Request: To establish an alternative sign program for Pharaoh's Hairum Salon & Spa, consisting of six signs totaling 29.34 SF. The program includes one 10.16 SF building sign (104.5" x 14"), four window decals (two at 5.82 SF and two at 3.74 SF), and one 9.62 SF circular hanging sign (42" x 42"). The awning above the front entry door will also be removed. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(c) Enforcement: No SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(j) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 10 File Number: A-074-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - Windows and Door Address: 603 Park Avenue Zoning District: R-1 Low-Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Arthur Morris, Tickle Realty Request: To replace five front vinyl windows with Marvin Infinity fiberglass windows and legalize the existing rear sliding patio doors. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: Yes; Work completed without a COA. SEQR: Type II: 48-5B(22)(a) Lead Agency: N/A Case: 11 File Number: A-075-25-26 Case Type: Certificate of Appropriateness - A/C Unit Address: 242 Oxford Street Zoning District: R-2 Medimum-Density Residential and East Avenue Preservation Districts Applicant: Arthur Morris, Tickle Realty Request: To legalize the installation of a front-yard air conditioning unit and plant five densiformis yews as screening. This project also requires approval from the Zoning Board of Appeals. Code Section: 120-194A(4)(a) Enforcement: Yes; Work completed without a COA. SEQR: Type II: NYCCR 617.5(12) Lead Agency: N/A Comment Information Interested parties may comment on any particular case. Comments may be provided in person at the public hearing or submitted in writing by email or mail. Written comments must be received by 4:00 p.m. on June 2, 2026, at: Email: Preservationboard@CityofRochester.Gov Address: Rochester Preservation Board, 30 Church St. Rm. 125-B, Rochester, NY 14614 For more information, visit: https://www.cityofrochester.gov/presboard.4162487 5-14-1t